War of the Ring: The Card Game Review — A Lord of the Rings Surprise - c4gamingstudio.com

War of the Ring: The Card Game Review — A Lord of the Rings Surprise

Shelfside
Views: 13050
Like: 491
We reviewed the original area control board game, so onto this card game version! War of the Ring: The Card Game is a 2022 release from Ares Games, designed by Ian Brody, trying to capture the magic of the Lord of the Rings fantasy trilogy, with 4 decks of cards and a shorter runtime. Play as Gandalf or Frodo in the decks to protect Middle Earth, or Saruman and the Witch King to spread corruption in the form of tabletop chits. With plenty of thematic rules, mechanics, and interactions that make Tolkien fans happy, including stars of the fellowship like Legolas, Strider, Gimli, and more, War of the Ring CG seeks to create the same epic tensions as the original tabletop war game. Does it create amazing stories like the predecessor? Does it need to? How much are the hand and randomness mechanics affected by trying so hard to be faithful to the original? Are the Shadow even depicted in a similar way as in the board game or original lore?

Check out Grinding Gamers Tees:

Table of Contents:
Intro & Overview – (0:00)
How to Play – (2:51)
Pros – (5:26)
Cons – (17:31)
Nitpicks – (29:15)
Recommender Score – (29:58)
Grinding Gamers – (35:20)
Ashton’s Personal Score – (35:54)

Support us on Patreon:

Our Website!

Purchase Games We’ve Reviewed! (Paid Link)

Shelfside Social Media:

Links to our other stuff:
Ashton’s Channel:
Daniel’s Channel:

Stuff Used:
“The Underworld” Music By Jamez Dahl

Music: Heroes Of A Thousand Battles by MusicLFiles
Free download:
License (CC BY 4.0):

#boardgames #tabletop #review

50 Comments

  1. When you said 7/10 I was like there's no way this game is 7, sounds more like 6. Then you reveal your real score. LOL

  2. To be fair, in the actual LotR story, the shadow didn’t launch any major assaults until halfway through the second book (the battle of Helms Deep). For most of the story, Sauron was mustering his forces in Mordor to launch a quick and decisive assault. If Sauron had sent forces out at the beginning of Fellowship of the Ring, his forces would probably have been stretched too thin to overwhelm the free people.My only gripe with WotR CG is how battlegrounds are chosen randomly. However, the game also includes a Fellowship of the Ring scenario where the battlegrounds aren’t random. I think a home brew scenario where the Trilogy rule set is combined with a player chosen order of battlegrounds would fix that. Maybe after drawing their hands, an attacking player could choose which battleground is next? Maybe the attacker could forfeit the right to choose the battleground in order to recharge their ring token.

  3. Never understood the "set up" complaint on big games. Crack a beer and chat for the 15 – 30 minutes or whatever it takes to set up. You are into board games. It comes with the territory. Feels like almost something you are supposed to complain about if you are into board games

  4. Did you get a chance to play the simplified 1v1 ruels in the back of the manual?

  5. I feel that the game misses heavily thematically, with the Mordor side seeming to have the disadvantage and the weaker part for much of the game. Your review considered that and was very informative for me, convincing me not to get the game – I was sold on it at first. Thanks. I find that other reviews of the game are overly positive and misleading, actually not only of this game…

  6. The art seems pretty mediocre. Either a real good amateur, or an amateur pro…

  7. This game is so great and much better than the long & boring boardgame!

  8. sounds like you're playing really weird, all our games either the shadow player has the upper hand a lot of the game, or it's really balanced and tight. also, playing the shadow player in the card game really feels like you have a lot of dispensable armies to throw around, so don't know how you play to have the opposite experience.

  9. RULES CORRECTION: Events are eliminated right after played, so you cannot spam events (e.g. The Black Captain). But you can spam Gollum! And hobbits abilities!

    This review took a little longer than anticipated because we had to play it 7 times! Let me know what you think of the Shadow's role.

    Written review: https://www.shelfside.co/reviews-2023/wotrcardgame-review

  10. Did the color grading just got better? Video looks sharper. As always great content, thanks!

  11. Where is Daniel? What happend? I alway cared alot about his recommender score.

  12. You should definitely do a comparison between War the Ring the Card Game and The Lord of the Rings Card Game, which focuses more on cooperative questing in Middle Earth with deckbuilding and a mana system similar to MTG.

  13. I think the game would have been better if it were not a LotR themed game. But it would not sell as much. GoT would have been better.

  14. Aragorn looks vaguely like Nicolas Cage in this artwork.

  15. Will you guys ever do a review of Sidereal Confluence? I'd love to hear your opinions and your opinions on the new expansion.

  16. best intro yet! and as always great in depth balanced review

  17. You should play Fantasy Flight Games' LOTR. It's a cooperative card game and I really like it

  18. I felt the cooperative parts of the game really added something that doesn’t really work at the scale of WOTR. My favorite moments were where my attempted read of my teammate’s plan went horribly wrong, or amazingly right.

  19. That intro made me laugh harder than any recent NPI or SU&SU video. You guys are seriously underrated. Wish you all the best.

  20. Sounds like LOTR needs to be made as a COIN game. I don't know if you are familiar with them, but it is a fusion of board and card game where each player plays cards to either take generic actions (move troops, fight, etc.) But also activate special events. (Awaken the Ents! Place 3 troops in Fangorn Forrest until end of round. You may move them once and fight.) Never played one, but it seems like it would work. Also COIN games are usually asymetric.

  21. Great review, love the work you put into them. No one needs a review based on one or two plays.

  22. I was so disappointed by the 2p modes. Can’t believe people are defending it. What a letdown.

  23. Events played are always eliminated afterwards, so you can not use The Black Captain multiple times per game.

  24. Man I got War of the Ring for Christmas and it is SO GOOD. I have played it like 6 times in 2 weeks after I got it and I fell in love with it. We also got pretty efficient at setup and the lenght does not bother you when the game is that epic.
    This card game seemed really cool when you were mentioning the pros but the cons… I cant wrap my head around that the shadow does not have many units :D. Also the randomness in locations seemed cool at first because of replayability, but giving a free people 3 points first turn seems boring.
    Thank you for the review.

  25. I played the board game 20+ times, and I have never exceeded 3 hour playtime. Most of my games last between 120 and 150 minutes, including setup ;).

  26. Like other people has mentioned on here as well, maybe look at Lord of the Rings The Card game as well. It's not a replacement for WoTR, but it does some thematic things well as well as engaging with the larger context of Middle-Earth. The only downsides are it's expensive as hell and the deckbuilding is hard. I'm also not convinced that one should compress WoTR into a smaller game as it is such an odd and unique game to start off with. Have you guys looked at Hunt for the Ring yet?

  27. Your War of the Ring box is looking a little worse for wear there Ashton haha good sign that it’s been well-loved and weathered many plays since we first saw it in your original review 🥲

  28. People complain that Axis is extremely hard to win in QMG but you get 6 experienced players and they will have the edge. I've not played this yet, but I feel that if it's like the Axis in QMG then the shadow side need to play both aggressively and seek double actions, it's a theme of all Brody games where you play as the "bad guys".

  29. Have you seen the "expert duels with experienced players" and bgg? Was posted by the developer of the game. Try it out and let us know what you think.

  30. the looks like a car you buy to only go down the street rather than getting to work. It doesnt look like it realizes its true pontential.

  31. Great review! I think 6/10 is spot on and fair. This game doesnt have a great identity. Competitive card games and War of the ring are 2 player games so its frustrating this was designed with 4 player in mind as a starting point and the 2 player variants are weak. This was one of my most anticipated games given War of the Ring is my favorite of all time so it was a big let down. Thanks again for the thorough review!

  32. The effort you put into this was fantastic. Well done.

  33. Have you considered some kind of mulligan rule for starting hand if you feel its too random

  34. I recommend you to try the Titans from łukasz woźniak seems to be scythe but with more actions of fighting not gathering resources

  35. Do you use a filter or change your color grading? Looks great – I'm trying to make my videos look sharper with the camera I have

  36. Wow, just discovered this channel! Your videos are really well done!

    The quick overview was spot on! You should make a playlist of quick 5 minute “how to play videos” for a bunch of games!! You do it better than most channels out there!

  37. Curious if you could do a review on battle of the 5 armies or hunt for the ring as well

  38. I just watched your review of War of the Ring tonight, subbed, and wouldn't you know my luck–you just put out a review of the card game!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.